manipulative framing

Melody and Gloria are preparing gift bags for their friend Janet’s bachelorette party. Melody insisted on being in charge of gift selection, as she owns her own party-planning business. She’s built her empire based on the unwavering fact that her finger has been on the pulse of edible underpants trends for twenty-six consecutive years. Her business has been featured multiple times in Bridezilla magazine.

Gloria eyes the cellophane-wrapped chocolate genitalia with disapproval as she assembles the gift bags. She didn’t object when Melody automatically assumed she should take charge, and now she regrets not arguing her case. This isn’t even Janet’s style at all. She glares at Melody, smugly scraping ribbon with scissors to make it curly.

“Janet likes pickled eggs,” she barks, startling Melody so badly she drops the scissors. “What the hell makes you think she’ll go for this chocolate penis nightmare?”

Melody stares at Gloria for a moment.

“I mean…” Gloria says, nervously crinkling cellophane. “We should go get some pickled eggs, too. Then there will be something chocolatey and something pickled.”

Melody knows that’s not what Gloria meant at all, but Gloria doubles down on it.

“Here,” she says, jumping up and grabbing her purse. “You’re the expert party planner. Keep doing this and I’ll go to the store.”

As Gloria drives to the store, she curses herself for biting Melody’s head off. She knows it’s not a good look, and she’s embarrassed. She internally reiterates her hope that the store is still open, and that they have pickled eggs. When she finds pickled eggs right where they always are in aisle 7, she sighs in relief because they have what she was looking for. Now she better get back to help Melody finish the gift bags. She doesn’t want to be that girl.

By the time she gets back with twenty-two jars of pickled eggs, she has convinced herself that she really didn’t mean any criticism towards Melody. She really was just concerned that someone in the group might be diabetic. But Melody is upset, and the whole living room is littered with curly ribbons.

Why can’t she get it through Melody’s thick skull that this was all just a big misunderstanding?